Here is an interesting question. A man walked across a road in central London after a wait at the traffic lights, in 1933. Suddenly he had a interesting and potentially very frightening idea. Who was he and what was the idea? So here is the whole story, it’s quite interesting. The road being crossed was Southampton Row in central London, and the man was heading across the road to Russell Square, see the image. He was Leo Szilard, a Jewish refugee from Germany and Hungary. He was a Hungarian and had lived through the chaos of the first world war, when Austria-Hungary allied with the Kaiser, not the best move as it turned out. So after the war Austria and Hungary separated and Hungary got a communist government which didn’t go well, so they then got one of those right wing nationalist assholes who appear from time to time, in this case a dick head called Miklos Horthy who took over in 1920 as “Supreme Warlord of the Royal Hungarian Army”. So this turd introduced “numerus clausus” laws, quotas based on ethnicity which basically made it very difficult for Jews to keep jobs in Hungarian Universities. So Leo and many others (notably Edward Teller, John von Neuman, Eugene Wigner etc.) left Hungary. Most of them initially went to Germany, but of course that didn’t last too long as another asshole, you know who, took over there. So they dispersed to the US, England and other places taking their impressive brains with them. Leo was living in a suitcase near Southampton Row (he was a very small man) and was going to the numerous libraries around there reading all the new physics. In 1933 scientists knew from the work of Rutherford the little known fun fact that matter was mostly empty space surrounding tiny atomic nuclei. So the nucleus contained positively charged protons and orbiting them were negatively charged electrons with relatively vast spaces in between. It was clear that the atomic nucleus contained something else besides protons as, with the exception of that of Hydrogen, nuclei were twice or more times as heavy as predicted from their proton content. In 1932 James Chadwick produced the first evidence that a heavy, uncharged nuclear particle existed, published in a Nature paper entitled “Possible existence of a neutron”. (he was more confident in later papers). So the extra nuclear weight was neutrons, things about as heavy as protons but uncharged. So Leo suddenly saw that if you bombarded a nucleus with a neutron it would not be deflected away by the positive charge of the nucleus and so could do some serious damage, possibly causing the nucleus to split into smaller parts, releasing huge amounts of energy. From the work of the Curies it was clear that nuclei of large elements such as Polonium, Radium and Uranium would spontaneously degrade releasing large amounts of energy. Could you induce nuclear degradation by bombarding some of these elements or certain isotopes with neutrons? Seemed likely. If during the splitting the nucleus produced two or more neutrons these could go on and split more similar nuclei, producing a chain reaction. This could be controlled leading to heat to spin a turbine and generate electricity or more ominously to produce a very powerful bomb. Leo had no idea which elements or isotopes would produce two or more neutrons on being hit by one, if in fact any did, so he was being very speculative. But he saw the potential and actually filed a patent for the idea as “neutron-induced nuclear chain reaction”, which was subsequently awarded by the British patent office but kept secret, I wonder why. In the late 30s, Lise Meitner and Otto Frisch (and Otto Hahn and Fritz Strassman) showed that neutron bombardment of Uranium in fact caused Uranium nuclei to split producing large amounts of energy and the element Barium, a much lower molecular weight element. Hahn and Strassman had seen this from work done in Germany and published their results. However Mietner, being Jewish had by then moved to Sweden where she and her nephew Frisch, a physicist then working with Niels Bohr, figured out what had happened, which they published in a seminal paper in 1938. Frisch knew about cell division, referred to by biologists as fission, and so the term nuclear fission was born. The next question was how many neutrons were emitted on fission of large elements. So Zinn and that guy Szilard again worked on this and in 1939 found that each fission event on Uranium resulted in the release of at least 2 neutrons, so the nuclear reactor and the atomic bomb were both feasible. And so the atomic age started. It was a scary time, what with the second world war about to start, as many very good nuclear physicists remained in Germany, think Max Planck, Otto Hahn and Werner Heisenberg. So it was quite possible that Germany might develop the atomic bomb first and then bye bye New York and London. However Germany and Hungary had also lost some of their very best, Szilard, Klaus Fuchs, Edward Teller, John Von Neuman, Eugene Wigner and many others. And the fascist windbag Mussolini did the same thing with Italian scientists. Enrico Fermi fled Italy because his wife was Jewish, and as a result the first functioning nuclear reactor was in Chicago, not Rome. Horthy, Mussolini and Hitler had driven away the very people who might have given them the bomb, all of those mentioned here later working on the Manhattan project. See how stupid these right wing assholes are? In fact Szilard arguably started the Manhattan project. In 1939 he visited his buddy Albert Einstein who was at the time the best known scientist in the world. They wrote a letter to FDR outlining the existential dangers if Germany got to the atom bomb first, which resulted in the Manhattan project, and the rest is history.
Author: gerry521
The Screwed-up Future of US Science; Precipitous Decline as Governmental Policy
As some of you know as a boy I was interested in science and wanted to make a career in scientific research. So I got a PhD from King’s College London in 1980 and them worked in Germany for 6 years. Where to go next? I felt I had seen British and German science and so thought about other places to try out. The most obvious place with decent labs and scientific culture was the US.
So it was logical that I then applied for and managed to get a job as assistant professor at the University of Florida (UF) in 1984. But why did I decide to go to the US? My younger self wasn’t organized enough to write down a list of reasons, but if he had I think he would have jotted, in order;
1. Good well funded labs and universities. Then as now the majority of the world’s most prestigious, best funded, successful, well-respected universities and institutes were in the US.
2. A decent scientific culture and respect for science based reality. Perhaps not universal in the population, but hell, they got to the moon.
3. Good pay and a high standard of living. The pay in a US university was better than that in the UK and Germany. And to a European, US food, gas, rent, house and land prices were at that time significantly lower.
4. Parks, better climate, natural beauty and all that. I’d been around the US a little and clearly there were some great state and national parks and a lot to see. And much of the US had a more appealing climate then that in the often cold, wet and dismal UK and Germany.
5. Multicultural melting pot. The UK and to a lesser degree Germany were also multicultural melting pots and I had no problems with Turks, Jews, Muslims, Arabs, Chinese, Indians, Pakistanis, in fact any kind of non-Anglo. So foreigners didn’t bother me at all, in fact I liked them and was interested in their cultures and food.
6. A stable democratic government with respect for the rule of law and good relations with other democracies. This was a given in those days. Of course it was clear that the US was considerably more right wing than Europe and there were occasional outbursts of craziness, but apart from Nixon and McCarthy, things looked reasonably stable. Of course there were other lesser problems, I didn’t like the then President Reagan and right wing politics much, I thought the gun and drug cultures and resulting problems were crazy and I was not impressed by the average education level, but I figured I could deal with all of that.
There were some negatives, notably the only partially functional US health care system, but I was young and healthy and had not committed to more than a few years in the US, so this was not a big issue. So I took the job in UF and I think I was pretty successful. I didn’t win a Nobel Prize but I was reasonably well known in my area of research and published quite a lot of fairly decent peer reviewed publications, IMHO. I also started a small biotech company initially with the help of UF which grew surprisingly well so that I retired rather early from UF to concentrate on running that. This company has generated jobs for me and several others, so nobody can say I am taking an American’s job, I made jobs for myself and several others. So I am a minor example of the American dream. I came to the US with basically nothing and contributed enough to benefit both me, others and the US in general.
Supposing the 1984 young me got somehow transported to that lab in Germany now and was thinking about where to go next. OK…
1, Good well funded labs and universities; is that true now? Trump hates universities as they believe in things like diversity, equity and inclusion which he doesn’t like except when applied to overweight intellectually challenged old white men like him, or white South Africans. He also has no respect of real facts and actual reality, another significant count against universities, which of course function to deal with the world as it really is. Finally “well funded” is largely dependent on federal dollars from NIH, NSF, DOD, VA and other federal agencies. The Trump regime doesn’t like those either and is firing their staff, blocking grants which have any hint of subjects he doesn’t like and making it difficult to make use of already funded grants. So the US just isn’t like it was in 1984, would I risk moving from Germany to the US under these conditions? How about;
2, A decent scientific culture and respect for actual science. Americans are taught to be very confident about expressing their opinions which would be good if it melded with respect for expertise, knowledge, facts and data, but that respect is obviously sometimes missing. This was present but mostly under control in 1984 but now science denialism is much more widespread and unfortunately a major part of the current hopelessly crap government. Stupid ideas abound. Vaccines cause autism, evolution is not real, climate change is not happening or maybe it is but is not a big threat, there are only two sexes, Covid-19 was made in a lab etc. etc, all brought to the boil by silly rubbish posted on numerous fake news generating right wing sites. There are many people in government now who believe in some or all of this stupid nonsense. Worse, the problem of doing something about climate change is going backwards due to science denial paid for by the deep pockets of the rotten corrupt evil lying fossil fuel industry. 1984 was 4 years prior to James Hansen testifying before the US senate, pointing out the likely problems from fossil fuel induced climate change. However in 1984 there were already warning signs if you were reading science journals, but at that time we thought the threat was quite distant. Now anyone with no previous bias can see the climate has got much more threatening and all predictions suggest more changes at an ever accelerating rate. So the last 10 year were the hottest 10 years on record, 2024 was the hottest single year on record, and sea levels are rising at an accelerating rate, now almost a quarter of an inch a year. I still read the best science and economics journals and all of those, universally, treat climate change as a very real and pressing issue which needs to be seriously dealt with. So it was disappointing that climate change was hardly mentioned during the last US election and was very low on voters list of important issues, which says a lot about the average voter IMHO. And of course the EPA is being defunded, sensible regulations are being removed or ignored and funding for alternate energy is being cut. Worse those crappy gas and diesel guzzling smelly inefficient rubbish ICE cars are being supported while much better and more fun electric cars are not being supported. So 2, look like a firm no also.
3. Good pay and high standard of living. That of course depends on a stable research job for me in 2025 US on which I could build a career. Bearing in mind 1 and 2, this looks pretty questionable, would I be prepared to risk it? Probably not. And general standards of living have relatively declined for most people in the US as wages have increased less quickly than prices for rents, houses, land, insurance, food etc. So while some things are still cheaper in the US, one being gasoline, most things are now pretty comparable in price or more expensive, so the financial incentive to move to the US, even if you can get a job, is now reduced. Also of course the over expensive and inefficient US health care system is now a significant disincentive. And if you planned a family good luck paying for child care and education.
4. Parks, better climate, natural beauty and all that. Well the current crappy regime is firing employees at national parks and trying to close down many of them. I suppose they will get this under control and keep the most visited ones open eventually, but who knows? And of course even the climate is not what it was. We have always had hurricanes in Florida but they are becoming more intense and damaging every year. I am forced to carefully monitor the storm potential every summer so as to prepare backup systems, buy tinned food, toilet paper, collect water etc. to be ready for likely power outages. In England and Germany power outages hardly ever happened, in Florida, due to downed power lines, the power often goes out, sometimes for days and sometimes multiple times in a hurricane season. Apart from anything else this has resulted in a metastasizing insurance crisis in Florida, California and other states at particular risk from climate change. This of course impacts homeowners and groups thinking of setting up companies. And the climate is getting more and more extreme all the time. Would the 1984 me take a job in Florida or California in 2025, always assuming one was available? Maybe I’d consider somewhere apparently less prone to climate change, Boston, New York or somewhere, though of course issues 1-3 would still be top of my mind, I would likely have already ruled the US out for the combination of those reasons.
5. A multicultural melting pot. Well the US is still a multicultural melting pot but for how long? Clearly the current government doesn’t like any kind of non-white non-male non-Christian, so interesting new immigrants and their cultures and foods won’t be coming here except in very small numbers. And non-white non-male non-Christians are clearly getting marginalized all over. While I am white and male, I have always been a fervent and devout non-Christian, so don’t fit well with the current regime. I am not gay or transgender but a rapid anti-fascist and anti-right wing billionaires, which might get me into trouble. And a lot of the US right wingers don’t like any kind of immigrant, even white males like me, I’ve seen that myself. Another reason for me to look elsewhere.
6. a stable democratic government with respect for the rule of law and good relations with other democracies. The US government has never looked more unstable and less democratic then today, with someone in charge who looks more and more unhinged every moment. And rule of law? Forget that, Trump pardoning criminals and attempting to prosecute DOJ employees who previously were just doing their jobs in investigating his numerous legal transgressions. And ignoring and boasting about ignoring the judiciary over and over again. And while in 1984 I knew that the US sometimes drifted from an ethical foreign policy, think overthrowing democratically elected Iranian and Chilean governments, the failed attempt to invade Cuba and the fiasco of Vietnam, it seemed that the US did basically at some sort of level believe in democracy and human rights. Of course none of that is true now, previous allies are adversaries, NATO is scorned even though it has guaranteed peace in most of Europe for 80 years while the Trump regime aligns with one of the worlds very worst, that evil little turdy dwarf Putin, and those other petty and evil dictators, Xi and Kim. And the US used to have good relations with many allies and generated enormous amounts of goodwill from USAID and other programs. All that is over for now anyway.
So the 1984 me would probably go back to the UK, or stay in Germany, or maybe France, Scandinavia, Israel, Saudi Arabia, Australia, New Zealand, Singapore, anywhere but the US. Something like this happened before. Germany was the world’s high tech center for Physics, Chemistry and other hard sciences before Hitler came along. When a country has such scientific dominance the best scientists from other countries flock there and further strengthen the science in that country. So scientists from all over the world worked in Germany in the 1920s and 1930s. Of course when Hitler came into power, many of these fled or were otherwise neutralized, you know how, and the US and UK did very well out of the surviving immigrants and refugees. So the stupid racist white trash Nazi regime lost German scientists like Albert Einstein, Danes like Niels Bohr and Hungarians like Leo Szilard, Edward Teller, Johnny Von Neuman and Eugene Wigner. These and many others had productive and militarily highly impactful careers in the US. In parallel the other fascist wind bag Mussolini lost Italy’s best scientists, notably Enrico Fermi who made the first nuclear reactor in Chicago, not Rome. The Soviets also lost a lot of excellent brains following their invasions of central Europe, one notable example being George Gamow. And of course the outstanding Hungarians I mentioned above had absolutely no interest in returning to Soviet occupied Hungary. These people together pioneered things like computers, nuclear energy and the atom bomb. So by being really stupid the Nazis and Fascists did a lot to aid the collapse of their own rotten regimes and the loss of talent meant that Soviets had to play catch up with the west for years after the second world war. It’s almost like totalitarianism doesn’t work isn’t it? And because at one time the Nazis looked like they might invade and occupy the UK, the Brits gifted the US their prize cutting edge technologies, notably microwave radar, jet engines and the prototype of the Manhattan project. So look it up, American radar was heavily influenced by the work of Randall and Boot, the first American jet aircraft had a British engine and the top secret “Tube Alloys” program eventually resulted in the Manhattan project. It’s almost as if foreigners can be useful. I’m not claiming that the US had no native scientists, it did, but these and other immigrants gave the country considerable advantages over the rest of the world. And how about this; the Chinese born scientist Qian Xuesen came to the US in 1935 and trained at MIT and Caltech. After working on the Manhattan project he cofounded the NASA Jet Propulsion Lab and had faculty positions at MIT and Caltech. He was regarded as being a genius, but got investigated for spying during the McCarthy era, another right wing bolus of unsubstantiated made up paranoia. So he was stripped of security clearances at the DOD where he had been a colonel even though there was no evidence that he was in fact a spy. He was subjected to house arrest for 5 years, apparently the US did not want his expertise to get to China. He finally got deported back to China in 1955, whwn he was in exchange for US pilots shot down over Korea. And guess what happened then? He was put in charge of China’s rocket program, essentially giving the Chinese the expertise to develop their own cutting edge weapons. One of his projects was the Silkworm, widely sold including to Iran who used them to attack US flagged tankers. That worked out well didn’t it? The US’s self inflicted loss was China’s gain.
To get back to the 1984 me in 2025; Perhaps I and/or he would pass for now on looking for a job in the US and check back in a few years in the hope that this nonsense regime got replaced by something more normal and sensible. But right now as outlined above, a definitive no, no, no, no, no, no and an overall are you f**king kidding me? In fact all 6 reasons for wanting to go to the US in 1984 have become 6 good reasons for not going now. All over the world there are well educated talented young people with highly marketable skills who are now probably thinking about the same as I would have done. This is a huge problem, the US has done great out of immigrants, not just the ones fleeing the Nazis, Fascists and Soviets as noted above. So Google/Alphabet cofounder Sergei Brin is Russian, Intel cofounder Andy Grove was Hungarian, Apple cofounder Steve Jobs was the son of a Syrian immigrant, Jensen Huang, founder of Nvidia is South Korean and I could mention SpaceX, Tesla, Boring, Neuralink etc. etc. founder or with some sort of roll anyway for Elon Musk who is South African. And there are many more, in fact a staggering 46% of the Fortune 500 companies had an immigrant or child of an immigrant as cofounder. The injection of this foreign talent has obviously had enormous impact on the US economy and it looks like this injection will now greatly fall or even stop all together. So that means that people who could be generating new technologies and industries in the US will just do it somewhere else. And what is the basis of current US military power? It is dependent on things like nuclear weapons, radar, computers and jet engines, sounds familiar? The US is already struggling in competition with China. In 1986 and onwards I taught academically top notch Chinese, Indian, Korean and other foreign graduate students in UF, only the very best were accepted. In fact their transcripts were way better than those of US student applicants. The immigrants got PhDs with no problems and almost all of them would then stay on in the US, adding their talents to the US pool. Now they will all either stay in China, India, Korea or wherever or go somewhere else but not the US. I know that many young American born scientists are currently wondering if they can make any kind of career in the US so that many are looking at the other places where you can do research, Canada, UK, Germany etc. etc. And the power of US science comes from the very talented researchers at places like the Howard Hughes Medical Institutes, Harvard, Janelia, the Rockefeller, UCLA, Stanford, UCSF etc. etc. The leading figures at these places are now being actively recruited by foreign institutions. So the US is not only incentivizing talented people not to come here but also incentivizing talented US scientists here now to go somewhere else. As in the past the strongest economies and war winning states are those with the best grasp of science and innovation. So how is the decimation of universities and research good for the long term future of the US?
In fact I wonder what this rubbish regime is thinking. It’s already clear that the US is losing the race for the future with China. China makes great AI, is already dominating solar panels, batteries and other alternate energy products and their electric cars will shortly eradicate most of the legacy European, Japanese and American auto makers, by the end of this decade if not before, see if I’m right. China has far more people, far more well trained engineers and scientists, better general education, a stronger work ethic, great funding for research and business set up and is clearly the only current economy competitive with the US. That economy is growing more than twice as fast as that of the US, so will overtake the US pretty soon. Going forward the inward looking US with little innovation will be overtaken by an unstoppable China and new cutting edge technologies will emerge more and more from China and other advanced countries, not the US. The denial of climate change in the US is ridiculously stupid as it slows the necessary progress away from fossil fuels which is inevitable and is happening pretty much everywhere else in the world. In a few years the US is likely to have a vast store of useless fossil fuel which nobody wants, fleets of obsolete ICE vehicles, and will have lost the ability to compete with China which will completely own all renewable technologies, not to mention AI and whatever new technologies emerge. China will have ultra clean air and so a much healthier population while Americans continue to breath in rotten dirty fossil fuel derived carcinogenic smelly smutty crap for no good reason. So the US is on a path that can only lead to rapid decline while China gets more and more powerful, not a formula for a viable US or a stable world. So why on earth is this happening? Clearly Trump is just not right in the head, but Musk is a smart guy. It now seems clear that Musk realizes that the silly DOGE thing was very poorly executed and will be highly counterproductive, so he is distancing himself from it, although the damage has now been done. Is overwork, hubris and ketamine the problem? Hopefully the rapid decline in popularity of the Trump/Musk regime will result in the republicans losing the House and Senate, which might stop and possibly reverse some of this nonsense. But I fear that the US is stuck with this regime which clearly does not believe in any version of democracy. Again history is informative, Hitler was actually elected by a minority of the population but all the same democratically. Once in power he shut down the free press and by intimidation consolidated all power in himself and the evil Nazi party, and you know how that worked out. Tell me that something like this is not happening now.
More Covid Crap
A friend sent me a link to this video, asking me of my opinion (here). IMHO this video is basically rubbish from beginning to end and I’m going to write an extensive review of all the silly crap in it. But for now;
In the video Dr. Robert Malone MD claims to have invented the mRNA vaccines and has claimed this in several other venues. Did he though? He worked as a graduate student in a PhD program in UCSD and the Salk Institute in the late 80s. He wrote one paper here showing that mRNA containing sequence encoding a reporter protein could be mixed with lipofectin, a commercial lipid product, and applied to mammalian cells grown in a dish. The cells then expressed the reporter protein. How surprising was this? Lipofectin was already widely used to introduce DNA into cells for expression studies so it wasn’t exactly stunning that with a bit of playing around with conditions you could do it with mRNA also. A step forward but hardly a breakthrough. A second paper lists Malone as second author here, and this shows that certain of his mRNA constructs and others could be injected into the muscles of mice and express encoded reporter proteins there. In this case the lipofectin was not used, the mRNA was just injected directly. Typically the first author on a paper is responsible for most of the work and second authors did some of the work but basically had a lesser role. The work was done in Madison, Wisconsin, not the Salk or UCSD, and it appeared in 1990, by which time Malone had quit the PhD program, he later went on to obtain an MD degree. On this basis he is claiming he invented the mRNA vaccines. While he may have thought that mRNA might one day be used to develop vaccines I seriously doubt that nobody else had the same thought. At the time proteins were being routinely expressed in cells using engineered DNA, and the added DNA made mRNA which made the protein. It was obvious that putting in mRNA was a more direct approach but everybody knew the problem with this; mRNA is extremely unstable. So to get anything useful you had to figure out how to stabilize the mRNA and get it into cells and you also had to figure out how to manufacture whatever you had developed in bulk. So practical mRNA vaccines did not emerge until 30 years later. Lipofectin would not work well with humans, a more advanced lipid formulation was needed and it needed to be coupled to the mRNA in a reliable way that could be scaled up for mass manufacture. These problems were solved in 2000 by Peter Cullis, Ian MacLachlan and collaborators at a company called Protiva, which developed the lipid nanoparticles and methods of manufacture used by both the Moderna and Pfizer vaccines. A problem was that the mRNA/nanoparticle complexes induced a strong inflammatory response which resulted in the mRNA being inactivated. The solution to this problem came in 2005 when Katalin Kariko, Drew Weissman and others showed that modification of certain bases of the mRNA would make the mRNA much more stable and much less inflammatory, see here. Much work was performed refining this approach, with safety, animal work and further research both in academia and industry over the next years. So everything, fortunately for the world, was fully worked out early in 2020 when Covid-19 hit. So Moderna and Pfizer could very quickly develop effective mRNA/nanoparticle based vaccines once the Chinese released the nucleic acid sequence of the virus which they did very quickly, on the 10th of January 2020. Despite all the nonsense spouted in this video, the Moderna and Pfizer vaccines are safe and very effective and will save millions of lives. And you haven’t seen anything yet, the mRNA/nanoparticle approach is being investigated for treatments for a host of other diseases. So there is talk of an mRNA Nobel Prize. One of the rules of the Nobel foundation is that a maximum of three individuals can share a single prize. It seems very likely Kariko and most likely Weissman and possibly MacLachlan or Cullis will win. Numerous others who have contributed to the mRNA work one being Malone. However, look at the awards Kariko has already got on her Wikipedia page. In summary Malone made a small contribution early on but if he says he deserves full credit for inventing the mRNA vaccines he is either self delusional or dishonest.
I wrote this based on my own research which included reading the original research papers I cited. I then found that there was a commentary in Nature concerning the history behind the mRNA vaccines, see here. Although the Nature article was longer and more detailed than mine we came to same basic conclusions. Interestingly they made at least one mistake- the second Malone paper did not use lipofectin/mRNA as stated in Nature, but pure mRNA.
Covid Crap
OK here we go again, more superficial and misleading garbage on the internet. Charles Eisenstein posting on, guest what, his own site charleseisenstein.substack.com, where he can of course post any stuff that he feels like posting, nobody to factcheck or review his ramblings. See this article here. In this he claims that humans have a need to execute pariahs for some vaguely described reason. Then apparently anti-vaxxers are the latest pariahs, though he does admit nobody is suggesting executing them. But then he gets to the paragraph below;
“The science behind this portrayal is dubious. Contrary to the association of the unvaccinated with public danger, some experts contend that it is the vaccinated that are more likely to drive mutant variants through selection pressure. Just as antibiotics result in higher mutation rates and adaptive evolution in bacteria, leading to antibiotic resistance, so may vaccines push viruses to mutate. (Hence the prospect of endless “boosters” against endless new variants.) This phenomenon has been studied for decades, as this article in my favorite math science website, Quanta, describes. The mutated variants evade the vaccine-induced antibodies, in contrast to the robust immunity that, according to some scientists, those who have already been sick with Covid have to all variants (See this and this, more analysis here, compare to Dr. Fauci’s viewpoint“.
The Quanta article he cited basically makes the obvious point that viruses mutate all the time and so if you have a lot of vaccinated individuals the virus will adapt to infect them. Scientists and clinicians are well aware of this and there is not much anyone can do about it so it may ultimately be necessary to develop new vaccines. So what? The present vaccines are extremely efficacious when it comes to stopping serious disease and death, but are a little less effective against the delta variant. It may be necessary to modify booster vaccines to account for this and later variants, not surprising, a new vaccine for the flu is made each year. However suggesting that it is better not to vaccinate is stupidly wrong. Without the Covid-19 vaccines deaths in the US would now be in the millions. And viruses mutate to infect more efficiently whether or not there are vaccinated people around. Remember that the delta variant originated a few months ago in India at a time when there was essentially no pool of vaccinated individuals.
So then he links to a post by Hooman Noorchashm MD, PhD who is supposedly a physician scientist (here). Hooman lists on Linkedin as being an assistant professor 2014-2017 at Thomas Jefferson University and assistant professor at the University of Pennsylvania from 2003-2006. Being an assistant professor is the first step up the academic ladder and leads to associate professor with tenure if the individual is successful as measured by peer reviewed publications, grants and other accomplishments. Dr. Noorchashm apparently failed to make that transition in either place and does not currently list an academic affiliation. He is now a practicing physician so it is a stretch to call himself a physician scientist; he did not make the cut as a scientist, twice. His article was posted on his own site noorchashm.medium.com. Of course anybody can post anything on their own web site. He goes on to contradict an article in the Wall Street Journal, just polemically, he does not cite any source for the information he claims, just mentions “the bulk of the studies on the topic of..”. Why not cite them? Obviously he did not learn much in his attempts to be a real scientist. There is nothing to suggest that the Wall Street Journal took any notice of this basically contentless tirade. Also, of course, there is money involved- he expresses his opinions, guess where, Fox News for which he presumably gets well paid.
The next thing Eisenstein cited is an article in Arutz Sheva, a journal I never heard of, see here. As with Dr Noorchashm there is no link to back up the claims in this article, so it may be totally made up rubbish for all I can tell. I’ll give them the benefit of the doubt for now. They claim that 7,700 new cases of infection occurred in Israel, “in the most recent wave starting in May”, not very specific. 72 people who had been infected got reinfected, while about 40% of the new cases had been vaccinated. So the majority, more than 50% who got infected were not vaccinated, which they don’t mention. Since Israel is one of the most vaccinated countries on the planet there are now more vaccinated people than non-vaccinated, so this tells you that clearly it is better to be vaccinated. Note they don’t say how many of the vaccinated and unvaccinated got seriously sick and died, a key bit of information. They also don’t break that down for the 72 reinfected either. Other recent studies show that the vast majority of those seriously ill and dying from Covid-19 were not vaccinated. Just search for “percentage of people in ICU unvaccinated” on any search engine and you will see numerous different reports all showing that the percentage of ICU Covid-19 patients who are unvaccinated is uniformly in the high 90s. So this journal implies that natural immunity is better than vaccines; Rubbish!! How many of the infected in Israel have died from Covid-19; the number is 6,559 as of today, about 5,200 before the vaccination program started. How many more would have died without vaccines? Obviously thousands more. So just a little thought will tell that this article is sloppily put together, misleading, just the sort of crap linked to by anti-vaxxers. And what about the site, Arutz Sheva? I wasn’t surprised to find that the site and a parent journal were founded to cater to right wing religious extremists, often not reliable sources of information. Of course an online journal is subsidized by adverts so it is in their interest to post as much click bait as possible, again follow the money.
In the same article is a link to a CNN video about this pathetic dishonest fraud Joseph Mercola (here). This is supposed to be a hit piece by CNN but by my estimation Dr. Mercola fully deserved to be hit, multiple times and then some more. Then, below the link to the CNN video there was a long tirade from Mercola about how poorly treated he has been and how the British secret service is after him and similar rubbish. This has now been taken down, I think Mercola is finally feeling some heat from all this bullshit he puts out. Of course at the bottom was a link to purchase his latest book. Again he is not a scientist, only an MD with the usual ego and delusions. He is the number 1 spreader of nonsense about masks and vaccines allegedly not working, vaccines causing death, basically all that rubbish. He of course puts all his crap on his own website where you can buy lots and lots of his worthless rubbish merchandise. Follow the money- he is making a decent income off of the clueless and gullible, some of whom will needlessly get sick and die. What selfish cynicism, especially from someone who took the Hippocratic oath. See this load of total nonsense.
Finally the article goes to an article concerning Dr. Fauci, to his credit Eisenstein links to a contrary view, although he clearly thinks his previous links were reality. This link goes to Business Insider, not a vanity site but a real serious journal with high standards, see here. Unlike all the above crap this quote Fauci accurately and directly cites two articles in Science, one of the world’s most rigorously peer reviewed journals. These papers are here and here. Two other papers are cited and can be downloaded from BiorXiv and ware currently not yet peer reviewed although this is in progress, these can be downloaded from here and here. See the difference? One side either does not link anywhere or links to dubious bullshit sites which do not detail their sources of information and the other allows you to read the data on which they are making their claims. This is just total rubbish versus science, I know which I am going to rely on. You’ll also notice that Fauci is not trying to sell you anything. To get back to Eisenstein’s garbage article, he later opines,
“For these reasons, I won’t try too hard to substantiate my belief that – and I may as well say it explicitly as a gesture of goodwill to the censors, who will thus have an easier time deciding what to do with this article – the Covid vaccines are much more dangerous, less effective, and less necessary than we are told.”
He of course provides absolutely no evidence for this. And there is none. And again;
“Nor is the foregoing analysis incompatible with the theory that Covid and the vaccination agenda is a totalitarian conspiracy to surveil, track, inject, and control every human being on earth.”
Just paranoid rubbish. Science is running the response to Covid-19 in the US with, at least now, relatively little input from the government. This is as it should be. Science is the only trick that humans ever developed which can lead to any new understanding or progress. You can pray to whichever of the numerous gods you prefer and you may then feel better but apart from that you will get nowhere. You can believe misinformation on the internet if you want but that gets you worse than nowhere, it gets you making really stupid decisions. Garbage in garbage out. I also noticed that Eisenstein wants you to get a paid subscription to his great thinkings, again follow the money. He is also not a scientist or even a clinician, being apparently a journalist and speaker. So he is even less qualified than the awful dishonest and useless Mercola and Noorchashm to have any meaningful opinion about vaccines. I’m going to edit my take on Eisenstein’s rubbish article and send it to him with an admonition to STFU since he is harming innocent ignorant and misinformed people.
Yet More Rubbish
I’ve been doing still photography since I was a boy, but recently I got into video a bit. Also I got interested in invasive species since I am one. Below is a video of a group of volunteers pulling up an invasive plant in north central Florida, the infamous Caesar’s weed, which grows like Bejasus here. All thanks go to Lara Colley for organizing this. Movie is rather large so can take a while to download.
Another little movie
I made another little movie. These are coontie seedlings, which are native plants here in Florida. They are also known as indian root, since the American Indians used to eat the underground parts of them. Coonties are primitive plants belonging to the cycad group which were a major part of the flora during dinosaur times. I don’t know why they wave around like that. This was actually my first movie with sound, need to learn more clearly. It can take a while to download since it’s fairly large.
Movie
I made a movie
Election Countdown
Browser not supported. Visit www.270towin.com
The Snake Bite Story
So anyway one Sunday in the evening maybe about 20 years ago I was cycling in the countryside outside Gainesville, Florida with my then ~6 year old son. I saw this colorful little snake at the side of the road. So it was a summer evening and snakes come out of the vegetation at that time and lie on the road as it is still warm, I suppose, I can’t read a snakes mind, but anyway they do do that. This means they get run over a lot and I feel sorry for them since they live here and humans and their great big fat fossil burner crap vehicles are destructive invasive immigrant species. So I decided I would save this particular little snake so I started banging it with the front wheel of the bicycle. It wouldn’t move, which might have clued me in, but it didn’t at that stage. So anyway I looked at it close up, it had no rattle, it was not flat grey and it looked rather like the harmless water snakes I had seen before. In fact I saw one just like it today, image above. So I just grabbed it by the tail and flipped it off the road into the vegetation. I did notice that it bit me and put two small holes in my right index finger, so I immediately thought “oops, that was not some harmless water snake, maybe getting bitten was a somewhat fairly bad thing”.
I showed my son the bleeding holes in my finger and we carried on cycling. So as we went on the finger got to sort of hurt a bit and started swelling. About half an hour later we got home and it was clear my finger was in some trouble. So I went to my snake book and found out that baby cottonmouths and/or water moccasins are sort of stripy reddish blackish snakes just like the one that bit me. They don’t look a bit like the adults at all, which are great big fat grey things. So I had been bitten by a poisonous snake- my finger now looked like a big fat sausage and I showed it to my wife who was shocked and horrified and told me to head down to the emergency room ASAP. Good advice I thought and off I went. So I sat there and eventually they saw me, but it turned out that very unusually there was another snake bite victim there, he got done by a rattlesnake. Riding his bicycle, he fell off, landed on top of a rattlesnake which tried to strike at his face but fortunately he put his hand in the way. So he got a nasty bite in the hand, better than the face, but still not good. So we bonded and said various negative things about Florida serpents, spiders, crocodilians etc. Anyway the meds looked at my finger and marked with a ball point pen how far up my hand the swelling had gone. That’s all they did, so I got to sit in the emergency room talking to the other snake bite guy and various other people with various other interesting and challenging things wrong with them. This was before smart phones, iPads, internets, whatever, so after an hour or so I got sort of bored with that. So I started to wander around a bit and there happened to be a little departmental office or something with a lot of medical type books in it. So I parked my carcass there and read everything there was on snake bites and in a couple of hours I knew quite a lot. So guess who gets bitten by snakes? Mostly males, mostly age 15-55, mostly alcohol related, whoda thunkit? So I was in the peak demographic except in my case it was not alcohol related, no really, I hadn’t touched a drop, honest. So I had amusing thoughts about drunk men picking up snakes and throwing them around or whatever, what asses male humans are. More to the point, what can you do about snake bites? Not much actually. The only therapy was antivenin which is this crazy thing where they inject horses with rattlesnake venom (what happens to the horses?) and the horse make antibodies to the rattlesnake venom and they get that out of the horse, call it antivenin, and inject it into the snake bite victim and it is supposed to neutralize the snake venom somehow.
So anyway I know a bit about antibodies and the literature also pointed out some potential flaws in the horse antivenin approach. One is that the cottonmouth and/or water moccasin is a different kind of snake from the rattlesnake, quite a distant relative, so any antibodies against rattlesnake stuffs may or may not, in many cases likely not, work on cottonmouth and/or water moccasin venom. Another is that if you just dump a bunch of horse antibodies into a person the immune system will quickly recognize the horse proteins as foreign and neutralize them and the person may also get an allergic response, then requiring a rat hole of more treatments, anti anaphylaxis drugs, expense etc. Finally I found out that snake venom from pit vipers, the group that include rattlesnakes, copper heads and that one that bit me, is a very complex mix of all kinds of nasty junk, proteases, nucleases, lipases and various toxins which serve to paralyze and also digest the tissues of the victim. Very nasty, and I couldn’t see how the horse antibodies could possible neutralize all the different components in this stuff.
So after three hours or so hanging around the emergency room the medics come back and with a ball point pen they marked where the swelling is on my hand, by now basically all of it. They tell me that they want to give me the antivenin but I raise the issues above and say I don’t want it. Nowadays this must happen to medics all the time, the unqualified expert, what with internets and all that, but in those days they were not used to being questioned by uppity patients so they got a bit sort of annoyed. Then it’s like midnight and they now want me to stay overnight and I flat out refuse. The finger hurts, the arm is now beginning to swell up dramatically but I otherwise feel fine and I am pretty sure I am going to make it through the night so I go home. So I have to sign something saying I refused the equine treatment and if I drop dead in the night it’s my fault and off I go.
The next day I go back to the emergency room as I am still alive and the medics look at me, note my continued apparently viable existence, but don’t actually do anything. So I go off to work, it being Monday, with my right arm sort of immobile and actually swollen to about twice the normal size, it looks like a big fat pink sausage. So I must look like one of those weird crabs with one normal arm and one huge one. Everybody notices this and asks me about it and so maybe thirty times I start out “well I was cycling down the road…”. So nowadays I would put the whole thing on Facebook or somewhere which would save a lot of time.
So I recovered but it took ages. The arm stayed swollen for several days and then the lymph node in my armpit swelled up to the size of a large orange, which was quite uncomfortable. It looked like a huge ectopic breast, so I know what it feels like to have one breast anyway, but eventually it went away. The next thing was that I got these weird blood colored stripes down the side of my body on the side where I got bit. These went away after a few weeks but the site of the bites still hurt and one of the bite wounds got really infected. It basically formed a fairly large hole in the finger, as I said a lot of the stuff in snake venom digests tissues. It got so bad that I had to sit with a bowl under my finger as stuff was just continuously dripping out. Also the nail on that finger went black and fell off. After about six months I got some antibiotics which stopped the infection and it eventually healed up, but not perfectly. The nail eventually grew back but it is now growing about half the rate of the nails on my other fingers, and the finger tip never got full feeling to return, so there must have been some nerve damage.
Later I found out that baby pit vipers are actually about as dangerous as the adults. While the adults bite and inject a small amount of venom, to conserve the stuff, babies inject all they have. Some advice- If you see a snake don’t mess with it. Also if the snake is not scared of you especially leave it alone. Non poisonous snakes seem to know they are harmless so tend to take off at top speed if they see you. Cottonmouths and/or water moccasins are not scared of humans, many times I have jogged past adult ones and they just did not move away at all. As noted above the small snake that bit me was not going to move off the road merely because I hit it with my bicycle wheel. Today I saw another one on a path at a local park and this also did not move when I and other people went by. It knew it was poisonous, just like the one that bit me, so it knew that you mess with it at your peril.
I once read about George Orwell’s experiences in the Spanish civil war, particularly when he got shot through the neck by a sniper, which he stated was “quite interesting”. He thought he was going to die, you can read about that in “Homage to Catalonia”. It was quite interesting to be bitten by a poisonous snake also, not so life threatening, but, like George, I wouldn’t recommend you try it.
Proven Lab Techniques
| This is basically an attempt at comedy I came up with as I was supposed to be the compere of a talent show put on by the local graduate students. So I presented it like a lecture about some experimental techniques which though widely used, they were likely not too familiar with, though in my lab we have done all of them, except the very last one, so far anyway. | |
|
Bottom or Butt
Blotting |
You have all heard to Northern, Southern, Western blotting techniques well, a further widely used technique is Bottom blotting, also known as Butt blotting, and comes about from leaving gels on seats and having someone sit on them. This is a technique which, though widely employed, has no known utility. |
|
Linoleum
Blotting |
A related technique is Linoleum blotting, which involves dropping a gel onto the floor tiles, picking it up again and then continuing with the experiment. The linoleum gel fragmentation assay is a related technique, which involves applying the gel to the linoleum with significantly more vigor. You then pick up the pieces of the gel and try to figure out how they fit together. Another technique widely used in my lab is… |
|
Note Book
Chromatography |
This technique makes use of the excellent absorbent properties of your notebook. You can apply your protein and DNA samples directly to your notebook, providing a permanent record of what you have been doing. When you see me doing an experiment you might come away with the impression that I’m a sloppy bastard, since my reagents appear to be splashing all over the place. In fact I’m making use of this powerful documentation technique. |
|
Projectile
PCR |
Another powerful technique is Projectile PCR, which makes use of the fact that PCR tubes are small slimy things which slip readily out of your hand, flying across the room and typically landing behind the refrigerator. When you look behind the fridge you find several other PCR tubes all with the labels dissolved in the oil, so you have no idea which is the one you lost. Because of this feature of projectile PCR is often used in combination with the extreme rigor of triple blind analysis. A triple blind study is one in which neither you, nor your coworker, nor in fact anyone else in the world has any idea which sample is which, or even if they are in fact PCR samples. If your hypothesis is still tenable after that kind of rigorous analysis it must have been really good. |
|
Desk top
concentration |
This consists of spilling your sample on the bench top and then returning it to the vessel from which you spilled it. Since you only ever get about half of it back, I estimate that this procedure might give you a rapid, one step, 50% concentration, though I must admit I haven’t actually quantitated the method in detail. |
|
Protocol step
excision |
One of the real problems of science at the graduate student level is that it interferes with your social life, but there are fortunately several techniques to get round this. One widely used technique is protocol step excision. It frequently happens that you have a very long protocol to follow and you want to go to a movie or get laid or something, so you look through it and it has 12 steps. Choose the two or three steps that look the most boring and time consuming and simply skip them, allowing you to get finished on time. Your mentor probably won’t notice, since he or she probably didn’t read the protocol and probably figured it wouldn’t work anyway. |
|
Protocol length
extension |
A complementary technique useful in many cases is protocol length extension, in which you typically change all 15-minute steps to 1 hour and all 30-minute steps to 2 hours. This has the advantage that you can honestly tell your mentor that you’re doing whatever the procedure is and still have time to go shopping in the mall, get your hair done, etc. |
|
Extended
overnight incubation |
When protocol length extension gets out of hand it frequently develops into Extended overnight incubation. Many protocols conveniently allow you to put stuff at –20°C overnight, and extended overnight incubation merely takes this to the logical conclusion, so you can keep the stuff it in the fridge for several days, weeks, months or even years. By then your mentor will probably have forgotten all about the experiment. |
|
Vehicular
Biology |
Another way to avoid messing up your social life is to use the techniques of molecular biology combined with motor vehicles, hence vehicular biology, a technique I invented when I was a postdoc. I wanted to go to this party, but I also wanted to get a gel run. So I got the gel, powerpack, bottle of buffer, staining solution and destain, loaded them up into my car, and went off to the party and set up the stuff to run the gel in the spare room. Unfortunately then I forgot all about it and the protein ran off the bottom of the gel, but at least I didn’t miss the party. This technique can probably be applied to most routine and time consuming lab procedures such as PCR, column chromatography and electrophysiology. |
|
Losing
stuff |
A further big scientific problem is loosing stuff in the fridge, darkroom or wherever you are experimenting. There are numerous variations on this technique such as out of situ hybridization, total loss protein purification, immunoerradication, gene misplacement therapy, and so on. |
|
Polymerase
Drain Reaction (PDR) |
Control experiments are very important in science, and one good one is the Polymerase drain reaction. This is basically a PCR in which you forget one of the vital components, and of course if you forget accurately there should be no product. However if you forget things in a way which lacks experimental rigor, you will get some bizarre product telling you that you need to forget things more carefully in future. |
|
Sink Filtration
|
The PDR reaction product ends up, as its name suggests, in the drain. This is a general approach applied to many experimental paradigms, usually called sink filtration, which is one of the most basic and frequently performed procedures for the elimination of experimental results. |
|
Bad Smells
|
Another problem in biology is using old reagents which have gone off. Since many of these smell bad this has generated a lot of techniques such as immunoflatulance, affinity putrefaction, restriction fragment stench polymorphism and Mouldy-TOF. The basic take home message from all these techniques is if it smells bad you probably screwed it up. |
|
Total Laboratory Pyrolysis
|
So finally if despite trying all of these techniques you still have spent several years as a graduate student without generating any useful data there is one technique of last resort. This is total laboratory pyrolysis, which involves burning down the lab and erasing all record of your misadventures and incompetence over the years. |